Difficult Investor Conversations
You're missing targets. Growth slowed. Burn is higher than expected. Your investors will find out. Better to tell them yourself, strategically, before they discover it.
Most founders delay difficult conversations with investors. You miss a quarterly target and you don't mention it for months. Then your Series B fundraising starts and investors do diligence, find the miss, and immediately discount your valuation 30%.
This is preventable. Investors expect ups and downs. They respect transparency. If you communicate early and often about challenges, you build credibility. When you hide problems, you destroy it.
The Framework
Tell investors bad news before they ask. Explain what happened. Show your plan to fix it. Update them monthly. This builds trust and keeps them on your side.
Why Early Communication Matters
Three reasons to tell investors bad news proactively:
1. They Will Find Out Anyway
Investors talk to customers, competitors, and other founders. They have a network. If you miss targets, they'll learn about it. Better to tell them yourself (and frame the context) than let them hear rumors.
2. Early Disclosure Builds Credibility
"We missed Q2 targets by 20%. Here's why and here's what we're doing." You look in control. Hiding it for 6 months then mentioning it? You look dishonest.
3. Early Communication Gives Time to Adjust
If you tell investors in Q2 that Q3 and Q4 will be soft, they can start thinking about solutions (extend runway? Adjust burn? Cut scope?). They become part of the solution, not the angry party when you fail.
Timing: When to Have the Conversation
Don't wait for scheduled board meetings or quarterly updates. Communicate as soon as you know there's a problem.
Bad: Wait for Quarterly Update
You realize in mid-month that you'll miss targets. You wait 3 weeks until the board meeting to tell them. Now it looks like you hid it.
Good: Early Call or Email
You realize in the second week of the month. You send an email or schedule a quick call with your lead investor that day. You explain. You get feedback. You address it together.
Rule of thumb: if it's material (affects valuation, runway, or Series B prospects), tell investors within 24 hours of realizing it.
The Bad News Conversation: What to Include
When you communicate bad news, structure it carefully. Here's the framework:
The Bad News (Clearly)
Don't bury the lede. Lead with: "We're going to miss Q2 revenue targets by $300K (15%)." Be specific.
Root Cause Analysis
Explain why. Was it: market conditions? Customer churn higher than expected? Sales cycle longer? Competitive loss? Be honest about what happened.
Runway Impact
How does this affect your burn runway? If you were at 18 months of runway, you're now at 16 months. Show the math.
Your Plan to Fix It
Don't just complain. Show your response: we're hiring a dedicated sales person, we're cutting non-essential spend, we're retargeting these lost customers, etc. Show agency.
How Investors Can Help
Do you need introductions? Board-level advice? Do they know customers you should target? Ask for specific help. Investors like being useful.
Revised Outlook
Based on your plan, what do you expect for the next quarter? Paint a realistic picture of upside and downside.
Pro Tip: Show the Trend
If this is a one-time miss, say that. If this is part of a trend (quarterly targets getting worse), be honest. Trend data is more important than the single miss.
Choose the Right Medium
Don't send bad news in an email that investors read in passing. Bad news deserves a conversation.
Phone Call (Best)
For serious issues, call your lead investor. Have the conversation. Gives them a chance to ask questions and process.
Video Call (Good)
For multiple investors, host a video call. Keeps it personal and allows dialogue.
Email (Okay)
For less critical issues or to summarize after a conversation. Include detail but keep it brief.
Board Meeting (Bad)
Don't save bad news for the quarterly board meeting. That's too late. You should have told them already.
Mistakes Founders Make
1. Over-Explaining or Rationalizing
"We missed targets because the market was soft and our biggest customer delayed and our hiring took longer..." Stop. You sound like you're making excuses. State the fact clearly and take responsibility.
2. No Plan to Fix It
"We missed targets. We're working on it." Vague. Investors hate this. Show the plan. What specific actions are you taking to fix the problem?
3. Overly Optimistic Recovery Plan
"We'll make it up in Q3 and be 50% above target." Unlikely. Be realistic. If you just missed Q2, assume Q3 is 10-20% better at best. Underpromise, overdeliver.
4. Hiding the Severity
"We missed by a bit." Investors then discover you actually missed by 40%. You look dishonest. Just say the number upfront.
5. Not Following Up
You tell investors about the problem. Then you disappear for 2 months. Don't do this. Monthly updates on progress against your plan. Keep them informed.
Scenario Modeling: Prepare for Questions
When you tell investors bad news, they'll ask: "What happens if X doesn't work?" Prepare scenarios.
Base Case (Your Plan Works 50%)
You hire sales person, retrain team, get back to 80% of target by Q4. Runway extends to 20 months. You can fundraise Series B comfortably.
Downside Case (Plan Doesn't Work)
New sales person isn't effective. You stay at current burn. Runway drops to 12 months. You need to cut costs or fundraise early.
Upside Case (You Execute Better)
New sales person is great. Customer retention improves. You grow back to 100% of target in Q4. Runway extends to 24 months. Series B at better terms.
Show investors the scenarios. Help them think through contingencies. This reduces their anxiety about the problem.
Maintain Long-Term Credibility
One missed quarter isn't a disaster. But a pattern of missing targets and explaining it away? That destroys credibility.
Build Credibility Through Accuracy
If you commit to Q3 recovery plan, deliver it. Even overdeliver. Investors remember whether you follow through. Make your word mean something.
Forecast Conservatively
After a miss, set targets you can definitely hit. Beat them. This rebuilds confidence that you can execute.
Communicate Monthly, Not Quarterly
After a bad news conversation, investors want frequent updates. Send monthly board decks showing progress. Keeps them informed, reduces surprises.
Reality Check
Most investors expect startups to miss targets occasionally. They understand volatility. What they can't forgive is dishonesty or lack of accountability. Be honest, take responsibility, have a plan. You'll be fine.
Facing Tough Investor Conversations?
Eagle Rock CFO helps founders prepare difficult conversations, build scenario models, and maintain investor trust through challenging times.
Get Investor Communication Strategy